5 biases that hurt students and family engagement

    Author Avatar
    By Heidi Otero
    Oct 16, 2019 8:40:45 AM
    Last year, Starbucks made national headlines when two black men were arrested for sitting in the store without making a purchase. The corporation quickly admitted wrongdoing and ordered all of its more than 8,000 stores to close for an afternoon of racial bias training. Unfortunately, similar incidents of unconscious biases occur every day, even in school classrooms.

    If the safety of all students is one of the main priorities in our schools, we must ensure they are emotionally safe from unconscious biases as well. Principals can play a lead role in helping teachers and support staff

    Sign up here to watch Heidi's free webinar 
    Redefining Equity in School Communications
    Thursday, October 30, 2pm Eastern

    understand how their own unconscious biases – social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness – affect how they engage with students and their families.

    As you think about the types of encounters you want your students and their families to have, identify opportunities to help your staff become aware of and avoid these five common types of unconscious biases.

    1. Beauty Bias

    Beauty bias can be interpreted as the outer appearance reflecting an individual’s worth. These students are often body shamed, humiliated and discriminated against without even knowing it.

    Ask yourself:

    How many times have you observed students’ characters being judged or labeled by how they were dressed?

    Why is it that more female students of color are dress coded and punished, as was documented in a 2018 report by the National Women’s Law Center? Click here for the updated report.

    Is the dress code at your school gender-equal?

    2. Affinity Bias

    Affinity bias is tending to be more receptive to people who resemble our lives in some way. For example, imagine a teacher saying, ‘’I always call on my favorite student because she reminds me of my little sister at that age.’’

    Or imagine you are at the winter choir performance and you see two very distinct families, the Conner family and the Almasi family.

    The Almasi family has a language barrier and dresses in traditional Arab garments, while the Conner family speaks English and looks like your perception of average, everyday parents. Ask yourself, who are you most likely to approach first?

    We tend to fear what we don’t know, and language and cultural barriers can limit engagement if we let them.

    3. Horns Effect

    The horns effect happens when we don’t like something about someone and, therefore, assume

    that everything about them must be bad. For example, a teacher might say, ‘’This particular student got in trouble today in class, so he must be a troublemaker.’’

    When we see or experience one negative interaction with someone, we can let it cloud our opinions of their other attributes. This has become a national issue with boys of color, who are three times more likely to be expelled or suspended than their white peers, according to the Kirwan Institute for the Study of Race and Ethnicity.

    4. Contrast Effect

    The contrast effect is the tendency to promote or demote something in a large grouping after a single comparison with another peer. Consider for example how our educational system tends to reward students based on academic grades versus academic growth. Each child is compared to one another in the classroom, but is that hard-earned A+ more important than the C+ if both children tried their best?

    Some schools have begun to shift this approach, asking what each child needs to be successful in school instead of assuming the better grade equates to the better student.

    5. Confirmation Effect

    The confirmation effect is looking for information that supports our beliefs and ignores details to the contrary. Imagine someone saying, “He’s from a Third World country, so of course he isn’t very well educated.” This is an example of confirmation bias due to believing a poorer country has less educated people.

    Now, transfer this to a school setting. We often think that parents who are part of a PTA/PTO are more engaged and value their child’s education more than parents who are not visible at school. But think about what might be keeping those parents away from your school: Are they working two or three jobs, attending night school or unable to speak English?

    Assess your unconscious biases

    As you reflect on the types of encounters you want for your students and their families, consider providing school staff with professional development that helps them recognize and avoid these unconscious biases. Such efforts will help affirm the worth and dignity of all individuals within your school.


    Author Avatar

    About the author

    Heidi Otero is Director of Communications for the Arizona School Boards Association and Vice President of Diversity Engagement for NSPRA. She is  one of the foremost authorities on equity and school community engagement and has presented keynote addresses and seminars across the nation. She can be reached at hvega@azsba.org